It’s hard to imagine many situations in which a manager would pull a pitcher with a no-hitter going, but it has happened 14 times in New York Mets history.
Thankfully, Mets Manager Terry Collins let Johan Santana go past his recommended pitch count on June 1, 2012, allowing him to make history.
The most recent abandoned no-no was on Sept. 15, 2010, when 20-year-old Jenrry Mejia left in the third inning with a strained shoulder blade.
Here is the list, from oldest to most recent, with their timestamps from our NoNoHitters.com count:
Aug. 10, 1969, Atlanta Fulton County Stadium, Atlanta
Nolan Ryan pitched 2 1/3 inings of no-hit ball against the Atlanta Braves before being pulled due to a thigh injury, according to the N.Y. Times. Manager Gil Hodges brought in an experienced no-no pitcher, Don Cardwell, who had accomplished the feat nine years earlier as a Chicago Cub. Unfortunately, Cardwell lost the no-hitter on the very next batter, giving up a double to opposing pitcher Jim Britton to make it 1,246 New York Mets games without a no-no. The Mets went on to win 3-0, with the Braves scattering five hits. Ryan would, of course, go on to pitch seven career no-hitters – none as a Met.
Sept. 15, 1977, Veterans Stadium, Philadelphia
Although Mets’ starter Craig Swan left the second inning of this game against the Philadelphia Phillies with a live no-hitter, there was no way Mets Manager Joe Torre was going to wait and see how this one would play out. Swannie opened the game by walking leadoff batter Bake McBride and letting him steal second. Then he walked Larry Bowa and let both McBride and Bowa advance on steals. Mike Schmidt followed with a sacrifice fly and the Mets were down 1-0. Swan got out of the inning with the no-no still intact, but walked the first three batters in the second before Torre gave the ball to reliever Bob Myrick. Myrick gave up a bases-loaded single to opposing pitcher Randy Lerch to make it 2,572 Mets games without a no-hitter. Phillies 8, Mets 3 in a game that featured nine Phillies hits.
Sept. 25, 1980, Veterans Stadium, Philadelphia
Mets starter Pat Zachry, who came over from the Cincinnati Reds in the Tom Seaver trade, had a perfect game through 2 innings before stepping up to the plate with Doug Flynn on first and Hubie Brooks on third with no outs in the top of the third inning. Zachry hit into a 1-6-3 double play, pulling a leg muscle trying to beat out the throw (Brooks didn’t score on the play.) Roy Lee Jackson took the ball in the bottom of the third and continued the perfection for four more outs before giving up a single to Pete Rose in the fourth – the 3,060th time the Mets’ lost their chance at the franchise’s first no-hitter. A four-hit fifth inning gave the Phillies a 2-0 lead, and they held on for a 2-1 win in a game with a total of six Phils’ hits.
April 12, 1981, Wrigley Field, Chicago
Tim Leary threw 2 innings of no-hit ball against the Chicago Cubs, with his only baserunner reaching on a two-out second-inning walk and advancing on a wild pitch. Leary got the third out, but was forced to leave the game with a sore right elbow, according to the N.Y. Times. Reliever Pete Falcone took the mound for the third and kept the no-no going until the fifth inning, when he gave up a one-out single to Ken Reitz to make it 3,077 games without a Mets no-hitter. The Mets won 2-1, but Leary would not appear in another Mets game until Sept. 25, 1983.
Oct. 3, 1981, Shea Stadium, New York
Mike Scott, who would go on to pitch a no-hitter as a Houston Astro five years later, retired all three batters he faced in the first inning of this game against the Montreal Expos. But, according to the N.Y. Times, Scott was dealing with a lingering elbow issue and Manager Joe Torre didn’t like how he was throwing. Ed Lynch took the hill for the second inning, and after getting Gary Carter to foul out on a pop-fly, he gave up a single to right by Lance Parrish for the 3,178th Mets game without a no-no. New York lost 5-4 in a matchup that turned into a nine-hitter.
June 22, 1982, Shea Stadium, New York
Randy Jones opened this home game against the Montreal Expos by issuing bases-on-balls to Jerry White, Mike Gates, Andre Dawson and Al Oliver, with the fourth walk scoring a run. Mets Manger George Bamberger opted for reliever Ed Lynch, who got the first two outs before giving up a Warren Cromartie single that scored two runs – both charged to Jones. Cromartie’s single would advance our eventual NoNoHitters.com count to 3,244 games. The Mets would go on to win this game in the “H” column 11 to 5, but lost in the more-important “R” column 4-3. It’s one of only two New York Mets game in their history in which the starting pitcher left the game without giving up a single hit, but also without getting a single out. (The other was John Maine’s one-batter 2010 outing.)
Oct. 1, 1983, Shea Stadium, New York
Tom Seaver, who returned to the Mets in 1983 after accomplishing his only career no-hitter as a Cincinnati Red, retired the first three Montreal Expos – and they would be the last batters he’d face as a New York Met. Seaver strained his lower back running on the wet turf, according to the N.Y. Times. Reliever Brent Gaff took the ball for the second inning and gave up a single to the first batter he faced, Mike Stenhouse, to make it 3,501 Mets games without a no-no. Gaff would get the 5-4 victory despite giving up four runs and 10 hits in 5 1/3 innings of work. The Expos tagged the Mets’ pitching staff for a total of 10 hits.
May 15, 1987, Shea Stadium, New York
Sid Fernandez held the San Francisco Giants hitless for four innings and had a 4-0 lead when he hit a two-out RBI triple to center. Fernandez injured his hamstring running out the three-bagger (according to Mets Walk-Offs, who was at Shea that night) but El Sid returned to pitch the fifth inning and fought through the pain to keep his no-hitter going. Doug Sisk got the ball for the sixth inning, and he walked one batter and hit another before blowing Sid’s no-no on a Mike Aldrete single to left. The hit advanced the Mets’ no-hitters drought to 4,022 games. Mets 8, Giants 3 in a six-hitter. The game marks the longest New York Mets outing for a starting pitcher that was pulled from the game with a no-hitter still alive.
Aug. 31, 1988, Shea Stadium, New York
Sid Fernandez retired the first three San Diego Padres he faced, but a knee injury forced the Mets to pull him for the start of the second inning in favor of Terry Leach. After striking out Carmelo Martinez, Leach gave up a single to Keith Moreland to make it 4,287 games without a no-hitter. Leach would take the 6-3 loss, giving up four runs on eight hits in 6 innings of work. The Padres would end the day with 13 hits and the injury would force Sid to miss about three weeks in August.
May 31, 2004, Citizens Bank Park, Philadelphia
During a rain-filled day at Citizens Bank Park, Matt Ginter had a no-hitter going for three innings, issuing just one walk. But after the second rain delay, Manager Art Howe decided not to send Ginter out for the fourth, according to AP. Howe put the no-no in the hands of Orber Moreno. Moreno got the first out but let Bobby Abreau reach base on a single for the 6,722nd Mets game without a no-hitter. Six Mets pitchers combined for a five-hit 5-3 victory in what is the second longest of these abandoned no-no outings in Mets history.
May 6, 2006, Shea Stadium, New York
Victor Zambrano retired the first Atlanta Braves he faced at Shea this day, but was forced to leave the game in the second inning with a torn flexor tendon, an injury that would end his season and necessitate Tommy John surgery. After getting Andruw Jones to go down swinging, Zambrano ran off the mound and into dugout, said Mets Walk-Offs, who was there. Darren Oliver took over and retired the fifth batter before giving up a home run to Jeff Francoeur, making it 7,024 games without a Mets no-hitter. Mets 6, Braves 5, in a game with nine Atlanta hits.
July 19, 2009, Turner Field, Atlanta
Fernando Nieve retires three of the first four batters he faces, yielding only a walk, but is pulled due to injury in favor of reliever Tim Redding. Two batters into the bottom of the second, Redding gives up a homer to Yunel Escobar, advancing our NoNoHitters.com count to 7,573 games. The Mets lose 7-1, as the Braves take three-of-four at Turner Field.
May 20, 2010, Nationals Park, Washington, D.C.
Mets’ starter John Maine leaves the game after issuing a lead-off five pitch walk to the Washington Nationals’ Nyjer Morgan. Raul Valdes takes over and gives up a Adam Dunn double in the second inning for the 7,686th Mets game with no no-no.
Sept. 15, 2010, Citi Field
Jenrry Mejia, getting the start for the Mets this night, leaves the game with a strained shoulder blade after walking pitcher Paul Maholm in the third inning. Raul Valdes takes over and gives up a sacrifice fly for the Pirates’ first run, but he finishes the third with the team’s no-hitter still going. In the fourth, Valdes gives up a Garrett Jones lead-off single in the fourth inning for the 7,790th Mets game with no no-no.
Some of the information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at www.retrosheet.org. Also, a huge thanks to Mets Walk-Offs for his research help for this page.
Pingback: Maine pulled with no-hitter intact | Mets No-Hitters History at NoNoHitters.com
Pingback: 7,686: Maine leaves after first batter, Mets win 10-7 | Mets No-Hitters History at NoNoHitters.com